in reply to Re: About the use of the plural form for the name of variables
in thread About the use of the plural form for the name of variables
I think great, but its not a table, use %veg :)
Excellent point.
Hmm, Perl Best Practices for naming variables says use %vegetable in the singular
This made me chuckle. It lead to me imagining Dr. Conway digging his own grave just so he could roll over in it. I know he went to a lot of effort to provide justifications for each "rule" he included. And I know he went to a lot of effort to document that his intent was not to have people blindly parroting rules without considering the justifications and whether or not each applied to their particular environment / situation / style, etc.
And yet, the vast majority of references to Perl Best Practices that I see are cases of people blindly parroting rules from it. (Perl::Critic is perhaps the most egregious example of this.)
But I give you points for providing a link. The link did include a justification:
Damian also recommends naming hashes in the singular, the idea being that individual accesses seem more natural: $vegetable{spinach}.
Note that I already said that I don't mind having the pluralizing 's' (or other suffix) being immediately followed by a "one of" syntax element (like [1] or {spinach}). They end up right next to each other and so I find no confusion results.
But I also find $vegetable{spinach} to be an example of a lousy use of a variable name. What are you tracking about vegetables, including spinach? Which of the things that you are tracking do I get back from $vegetable{spinach} ? I guess you might have a bunch of Whatever::Vegetable objects, which would make the name less bad.
I've seen a recommendation to use prepositions in the names of hash variables. For example, my %vegetable_obj_from_name;. But I realize that I relatively rarely have multiple hashes indexing into the same space of values. So I'm more likely to go with your advice of "It is a variable of limited scope, give it a name that is somewhat mnemonic but also short and thus faster to type and even to read... like %veg".
Thanks for the reality check and for the chuckle. (:
- tye
|
---|
Replies are listed 'Best First'. | |
---|---|
Re^3: Using plural form for variable names (Perl Best Practices)
by space_monk (Chaplain) on Nov 08, 2012 at 15:25 UTC |