It'll probably need tweaking constantly for different input, but it works for the sample data. I've no idea what $thing is though.

#! perl -slw
use strict;
$^W=0;

while( <DATA> ) {
    my( $authors, $title, $thing, $pub, $date, $comment, $no ) = m/
        ^
        -( .*? \. ) \s(?=[A-Z][a-z])
        ( .+ ) \.\s+ 
        ( [^:]+? ) : \s+
        (\S+), \s+
        ( \d{4} ) [^.]* \. \s+
        ( [^\[]+ ) 
        \[ ( \d+ ) \] \s* $
    /x;
    printf "   Author:'%s'\n"
        .  "    Title:'%s'\n"
        .  "   Thing?:'%s'\n"
        .  "Publisher:'%s'\n"
        .  "     Date:'%4d'\n"
        .  "  Comment:'%s'\n"
        .  "       No:'%d'\n\n", 
        $authors, $title, $thing, $pub, $date, $comment, $no;
}


__DATA__
-Lightfoot, J. B. St. Paul’s Epistle to the Philippians. Grand Rapids:
+ Zondervan, 1953 (= 1913). Classic commentary by one of the greatest 
+English-speaking NT scholars of all time. [2]
-Martin, Ralph P. Philippians. Rev. ed.; NCB. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 
+1980. Clear and informed. [2]
-O'Brien, Peter, T. Commentary on Philippians. NIGTC. Grand Rapids: Ee
+rdmans, 1991. Thorough and insightful comments on the Greek text. [1]
-Silva, Moisés. Philippians. Baker Exegetical Commentary. Grand Rapids
+: Baker, 1993. Sound comments on the Greek text. [2]
-Barth, Markus and Helmut Blanke. The Letter to Philemon: A New Transl
+ation with Notes and Commentary. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000. With o
+ver 500 pages devoted to a letter that was probably written on a sing
+le sheet of papyrus, this work will be consulted by all who want the 
+most thorough treatment of Philemon and avoided by the rest of us. [3
+]
-Bruce, F. F. The Epistles to the Colossians, to Philemon, and to the 
+Ephesians. NIC. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1984. See comments under “Com
+mentaries on Ephesians.” [2]
[download]

Output:

[23:43:10.06] P:\test>411598
   Author:'Lightfoot, J. B.'
    Title:'St. Paul?ÇÖs Epistle to the Philippians'
   Thing?:'Grand Rapids'
Publisher:'Zondervan'
     Date:'1953'
  Comment:'Classic commentary by one of the greatest English-speaking 
+NT scholars of all time. '
       No:'2'

   Author:'Martin, Ralph P.'
    Title:'Philippians. Rev. ed.; NCB'
   Thing?:'Grand Rapids'
Publisher:'Eerdmans'
     Date:'1980'
  Comment:'Clear and informed. '
       No:'2'

   Author:'O'Brien, Peter, T.'
    Title:'Commentary on Philippians. NIGTC'
   Thing?:'Grand Rapids'
Publisher:'Eerdmans'
     Date:'1991'
  Comment:'Thorough and insightful comments on the Greek text. '
       No:'1'

   Author:'Silva, Mois??s.'
    Title:'Philippians. Baker Exegetical Commentary'
   Thing?:'Grand Rapids'
Publisher:'Baker'
     Date:'1993'
  Comment:'Sound comments on the Greek text. '
       No:'2'

   Author:'Barth, Markus and Helmut Blanke.'
    Title:'The Letter to Philemon: A New Translation with Notes and Co
+mmentary'
   Thing?:'Grand Rapids'
Publisher:'Eerdmans'
     Date:'2000'
  Comment:'With over 500 pages devoted to a letter that was probably w
+ritten on a single sheet of papyrus, this work will be consulted by a
+ll who want the most thorough treatment of Philemon and avoided by th
+e rest of us. '
       No:'3'

   Author:'Bruce, F. F.'
    Title:'The Epistles to the Colossians, to Philemon, and to the Eph
+esians. NIC'
   Thing?:'Grand Rapids'
Publisher:'Eerdmans'
     Date:'1984'
  Comment:'See comments under ?Ç£Commentaries on Ephesians.?Ç¥ '
       No:'2'
[download]