That node is now up to 4 replies, and I see (with the option on) 4 replies on Seekers of Perl Wisdom
but 6 replies on The Monestary Gates
Update: the Gates use the cached repliesinfo information, while SoPW (to my surprise) actually counts the notes that exist. repliesinfo is set in note maintenance create and note maintenance delete, in code that
is subject to race conditions, but I don't see how it would leave the counts too high offhand.
I meant to post this under Discrepancies in the number of replies, but don't want it moved now because (cough, cough) moving nodes doesn't update the repliesinfo record.