|Think about Loose Coupling|
RE: RE: Experience Systemby kryten (Scribe)
|on Apr 27, 2000 at 20:21 UTC||Need Help??|
I think experience for voting should be retained.
It is nice to have a site that can value the participation of those who may not be so vocal, and allow them to feel more an active part of the site.
I am not a great fan of the bonus for unloading all your votes in a day. Some days, I just do not read enough good posts. even with rewarding good questions as well as good answers. (not because there arent any but because I do not have time) In this situation it is tempting just to throw votes at anything just to gain more XP, but I manage to resist. It would be better just to give out the 75% per vote.
While we are talking about the XP system, I don't like the inherent randomness of it. Just give .75 XP for each vote cast and be done with it. (Yay determinisim!)
If anything I think the experience gained from posting
is too much. Experience gained from a post should
be soley tied to the reputation that it recieves.
Thus useless posts that stay at 0 gain no XP for the writer.
Overall I think it is good that this site has things pretty much under control, and we can just sit around quibbling about refinements. We probably should make the most of it before we have to spend all our votes -1'ing hot grits :)
As a side point, it is interesting to note people's arguments and compare that to their number of posts :)