in reply to
Re^2: Perl 5 Optimizing Compiler, Part 2
in thread Perl 5 Optimizing Compiler, Part 2
Please correct me on this particular point.
Here's a fun one: how do you ensure that the finalization semantics of Perl 5 (thanks to reference counting) are in effect on an RPython platform? How about operator types? Iterator aliasing?
Does it support raw memory access, or do things that aren't hashes or floats have to be emulated with hashes and floats?
JIT is only a real advantage when you can use things like type specialization and escape analysis to create straight-line code that can make a lot of assumptions because you've proven them. You have to get the boxing/unboxing semantics right, and you have to have a deep understanding of the memory model of the target and of the hosted language.
(The same laws of physics apply when porting an existing language to a different VM. If you get dramatic speed improvements on all but a few benchmarks, it's a sign that the prior VM was pretty poor, not that JIT magic unicorn-flavored candy.)