good chemistry is complicated, and a little bit messy -LW |
|
PerlMonks |
comment on |
( [id://3333]=superdoc: print w/replies, xml ) | Need Help?? |
But what does noderep measure? Nothing useful. The largest
correlation noderep has with anything is "number of times
viewed". Just look at your own nodes, see which ones got
a high noderep. I bet most of them are in threads that have
been frontpaged, and are posts that you posted relatively
early in the threads. Almost all the time when I look at
my list of writings, and spot a node with high noderep,
it's in a thread that was frontpaged, and that I had an
early reply in a thread. Replying in a thread that's two
days old will hardly give you any XP, no matter how good it
was.
Another factor that plays in role in making nodereputation useless is the pressure to vote. People seem to eager to vote, get rewarded with XP to vote, and lots of people even use up all the votes they get on a day. I can see merit in having somekind of node reputation. I don't seen any merit in the system we have now. Abigail In reply to Re: Googlish approach to voting/XP?
by Abigail-II
|
|