To tell you the truth, I'm always split on this issue. I feel that C is better for learning the basic programming concepts, and makes you appreciate Perl more once you get to it. The other side is that by learning Perl first, you get to build interesting things a lot faster and in doing so often keep the student more interested. So it does depend on the student somewhat, if they're really interested in programming in general I'd definately recommend learning C first. Otherwise it's a toss-up, and since I'm terribly biased towards Perl, I often recommend C just to maintain some shred of objectivity ;-).
I definately agree with your point that learning Perl helps one understand C better, I know this was true for me. I also believe the reverse is true, C helps you understand Perl better (some experience in a *nix environment helps as well). Keep in mind, Whatever people think about C vs Perl as an introductory language, at least they're both not Java :)
| [reply] |
hehehehe...yes. I like your last statement. Although, I have never even attempted developing in Java, I have heard monster stories about it. No, not about the coding aspect but about how it runs. *shrug* I can only take what people tell me about it. I really know very little about Java.
As for the Perl vs C first and vice versa, you're right. It's all subjective. Everybody learns differently. And thank goodness too! If we were all the same it would be a boring life, ya know?
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
- Jim
Insert clever comment here...
| [reply] |
I came to Perl from a long C background, so most of the syntax wasn't the issue. It was the regular expressions that I had only touched on in UN*X that was my stumbling block (and many others' since they look foreboding and yet are a godsend). Now I love them, but it took me a lot of "tough loving" to beat them into my skull.
Usually when people ask me how to get into programming, I tell them to use Python. It's a great prototyping language with similar syntax to several other common languages. It has the same logic structures and (this is the key) forces good formatting habits. It is also easy to convert Python to C code as long as you make sure that you use options that are native to both languages.
We've all dealt with bad style, and I truly believe it comes from never being taught good readable style in the first place. By forcing them to tab their logic, it teaches them readability, which is extremely important as they move to other languages without strict rules of style.
Once they have a sense of readability, they can adopt their style to the language as they read others code and find what feels natural. Then, perhaps, their code won't look obfuscated on accident.
In reality, any language can be learned first, but I like to advocate Python because I feel that they will become better programmers in the long-run. Many languages give programmers the freedom to get set in their ways before they know what their ways are, and that is a problem.
| [reply] |
