<?xml version="1.0" encoding="windows-1252"?>
<node id="504850" title="Re^3: A Level Playing Field" created="2005-11-02 02:33:01" updated="2005-11-01 21:33:01">
<type id="11">
note</type>
<author id="26179">
tilly</author>
<data>
<field name="doctext">
History is far too complex for such a facile summary of an institution that existed that long, in that many places.&lt;p&gt;

It is true that they were fairer than most other legal systems of the day.  But they were still incredibly brutal by current standards.&lt;p&gt;

It is true that they helped shape many modern judicial systems.  But the British justice system, and its various descendents in the English-speaking world, are not among that number.&lt;p&gt;

It is true that the Inquisition didn't burn masses of people at the stake.  But they knew what would happen when they turned their victims over to secular authorities, and also had a role in convincing secular authorities to use that punishment.&lt;p&gt;

It is true that part of the reason that the Spanish Inquisition was singled out for so much criticism was due to Protestant politics.  But it is also true that they earned a good part of that criticism, particularly for their actions in the New World, and for their actions until Napoleon intervened.  (Read, for instance, [http://www.christianhospitality.org/pages_20items/torture.htm|this description].)&lt;p&gt;

It is true that the Inquisition gave many life imprisonment instead of turning them over to be burned.  But life imprisonment in the way that they did it could well have been a harsher punishment.&lt;p&gt;

It is true that the Inquisition did &lt;i&gt;not&lt;/i&gt; actually drive the Jews out of Spain.  But it did push for that to happen.&lt;p&gt;

It is true that most have an exaggerated view of how horrible the Inquisition was.  But it was still pretty darned horrible.  Furthermore when it comes to the appropriateness of having &lt;i&gt;Grand Inquisitor&lt;/i&gt; as a title on this site, the perception of people who are likely to be offended matters more than the reality.</field>
<field name="root_node">
504121</field>
<field name="parent_node">
504683</field>
</data>
</node>
