[SOLVED] File handle passing issue under *nix

[vsespb]

Some code:

main.pl:

use strict;
use warnings;
use IO::Handle;
$^F = 100;

pipe READHANDLE,WRITEHANDLE;
binmode READHANDLE;
binmode WRITEHANDLE;
WRITEHANDLE->autoflush;
READHANDLE->autoflush;
unless (fork()){
        exec $^X, $ARGV[0], fileno(READHANDLE);
        die;
}
print WRITEHANDLE "Test!\n";
close WRITEHANDLE;
wait;

subcommand1.pl:

open IN, "<&", $ARGV[0] or die $!;
binmode IN;
while(defined($_ = <IN>)) {
    print "line $_";
}
close IN;

subcommand2.pl:

open IN, "<&", $ARGV[0] or die $!;
binmode IN;
my $s = <IN>;
print "line: $s";
close IN;

Problem:

perl main.pl subcommand1.pl

hangs after first line, while

perl main.pl subcommand2.pl

works fine.
Also

cat subcommand1.pl | perl subcommand1.pl 0

works fine, meaning subcommand1.pl reads from file correctly.

So, I cannot understand why there is some kind of deadlock in subcommand1.pl?


UPD: SOLVED Re: File handle passing issue under *nix

[McA]

Hi vsespb,

as I have to do penance for my sarcastic answer in another thread of today, here my points:

1) You subcommand2.pl test is IMHO a false positive. As soon as you read twice you also get this stuck behaviour. Try this:

open IN, "<&", $ARGV[0] or die $!;
binmode IN;
my $s = <IN>;
print "line: $s";
print "Attempt to read twice:";
$s = <IN>;
print "line: $s";
close IN;

So, it's the same as subcommand1.pl. You're just kidding yourself.

2) As soon as you modify your main.pl to the following, it works:

use strict;
use warnings;
use IO::Handle;
$^F = 100;

pipe READHANDLE,WRITEHANDLE;
binmode READHANDLE;
binmode WRITEHANDLE;
WRITEHANDLE->autoflush;
READHANDLE->autoflush;
unless (fork()){
        close WRITEHANDLE or die $!;
        exec $^X, $ARGV[0], fileno(READHANDLE);
        die;
}
close READHANDLE or die $!;
print WRITEHANDLE "Test!\n";
close WRITEHANDLE;
wait;

You see, that the unnecessary ends of the pipe are closed. See http://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man2/pipe.2.html for the description.

Best regards
McA

[vsespb]

1) You subcommand2.pl test is IMHO a false positive.

Indeed, but my intention was to proof that it at least can read something and not hang (so, exec() call works like expected etc).


2) As soon as you modify your main.pl to the following, it works

Damn! You are right! I was trying version which closes READHANDLE, but forgot about WRITEHANDLE ! Thank you. I think it's solved now!

p.s.
I upvoted your sarcastic post, it looks acceptable to me.

[McA]

You're welcome. McA