Do you like your job? Not to be a smart-ass, but this sounds really bad to me. ESPECIALLY other people going along with it. Now the other stuff is up to your boss I guess, but I find the "over commented" part hard to swallow. I mean comments are what allow people to easily look at code without thinking "what was the guy who wrote this trying to do". To me this all sounds like a formula for disaster down the road. I'm not sure I'd be too particular on a boss ripping my code in front of everyone for being too clear either.
in reply to Re: How do you critique another person's code?
in thread How do you critique another person's code?