Beefy Boxes and Bandwidth Generously Provided by pair Networks
Syntactic Confectionery Delight

The Mythical Man-Month (20th anniversary edition)

by FoxtrotUniform (Prior)
on Aug 31, 2004 at 22:39 UTC ( #387349=bookreview: print w/replies, xml ) Need Help??
Order The Mythical Man-Month (20th anniversary edition)

Item Description: A discourse on programming techniques from a manager's perspective

Review Synopsis: Good for managers, not necessarily for programmers

The Mythical Man-Month is something of a legend among software-engineering books. It's spawned memes like "the second-system effect", "Brooks' Law" (Adding manpower to an already late project only makes it later), and the dread "Build one to throw away, you will anyhow". The 20th anniversary edition contains four additional chapters, written after the first book and with some new thoughts.

Brooks writes this book mostly from the perspective of a disappointed OS/360-project manager. As such, the book is mostly directed towards managers -- although programmers can benefit from it, a little. Brooks' main thesis seems to be:

the more people you have working independently, the more complex their communication must be. That communication is what drags down a software project into the morass of failure. Try to simplify the communication by:
  • Keeping the project as simple as possible. (The second-system effect is, basically, trying to cram in as many features as possible.)
  • Organizing programmers and staff into sub-teams that can work independently, connecting their components through well-defined interfaces. (Sound familiar? Brooks was preaching this dogma nearly thirty years ago.)
  • Maintaining terse, up-to-date, and useful documentation so that people can more profitably RTFM.
  • Separating architecture and design from implementation, and keeping the number of architects to a minimum, to ensure both a self-consistent design and a single authoritative designer.
Brooks also writes many good bits about scheduling (coding doesn't take as much time as you think; testing takes far more), division of expertise (good coders often make poor managers; don't "promote" them into management just to increase their seniority); schedule SNAFUs ("How does a software project become a year late? One day at a time."); and the like.

The thing that pissed me off the most about this book was the fact that Brooks has changed his mind in the intervening twenty years (he accepts data hiding, rather than rejecting it; and he no longer advises people to throw away their first hacks at a problem when most of the code is likely perfectly good) -- and he stuffs his diffs in the last few chapters, rather than re-writing. This may be chronologically honest, but it doesn't make for a terribly useful book. I pity da foo' who starts a big software project after making it only most of the way through TMM-M. While I praise Brooks for having the guts to write section titles like "Parnas was right, and I was wrong", I wish he'd taken the time to re-write the "wrong" bits instead of appending an erratum. (The other thing that pisses me off about the book is the author's use of end-notes, rather than footnotes. Grr.)

Programmers, especially programmers who work alone or in small groups on little projects, won't get much out of this book. What they get will probably be useful, but if you're going to buy a book to make you a better programmer, The Pragmatic Programmer is probably a better choice. Managers, on the other hand, should be required to read this book before they ever tell a programmer what to work on -- forced to read it at gunpoint, if need be.

  • Comment on The Mythical Man-Month (20th anniversary edition)
Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re: The Mythical Man-Month (20th anniversary edition)
by jplindstrom (Monsignor) on Sep 01, 2004 at 11:27 UTC
    I can highly recommend this book. To wet your appetite, here are some notes I wrote down in my use.perl journal while reading the book:

    Now go buy the book!


Log In?

What's my password?
Create A New User
Node Status?
node history
Node Type: bookreview [id://387349]
and all is quiet...

How do I use this? | Other CB clients
Other Users?
Others making s'mores by the fire in the courtyard of the Monastery: (4)
As of 2017-06-24 04:12 GMT
Find Nodes?
    Voting Booth?
    How many monitors do you use while coding?

    Results (556 votes). Check out past polls.