Not addressing any of the opinions presented here, but there are two factual error that I must refute.
First clue was Perl.com is owned by O'Reilly.
This is false on its face. See "whois perl.com":
Registrant:
Perl Consulting
2227 Canyon Blvd, #262
Boulder, CO 80302
US
Domain Name: PERL.COM
Administrative Contact:
Christiansen, Tom tchrist@PERL.COM
Perl Consulting
2227 CANYON BLVD APT 262
BOULDER, CO 80302-5634
US
(303) 444-3212 fax: 999 999 9999
Yup. Tom Christiansen. Last time I looked, he was not even an employee of O'Reilly.
And then there's:
Thirdly, Merlyn is here and he always links to and posts about his articles regarding Perl on the O'Reilly site or newsletter.
I've never written for "the O'Reilly site or newsletter". Ever. I've had an article or two on perl.com where I was
being interviewed, but I don't think I pointed to that (although I could be wrong).
I will not challenge the part of "merlyn is here", though. {grin}