in reply to
Re^3: How do janitors get fired? (sneaky)
in thread How do janitors get fired?
Hmm, IMHO this is a little extreme - I understand the points you make, but if an ex-janitor can show they have been an active and conscientious editor, and participated appropriately in the wiki, I do feel they ought to be allowed some route of appeal.
I make no comment as to whether jeffa would pass such a test or not.
Tom Melly, email@example.com