$ perl -Mstrict -Mwarnings -E ' no warnings q{qw}; my @file_data = ( [qw{target1,48,12,7 target2,17,16,2 target3,22,6,1}], [qw{target5,14,12,8,,3, target6,5,7,9,,,15}], [qw{target1,,,,,,13 target2,,,,,,8 target4,,,,11,5,6}], [qw{target1,,,,51,8 target2,,,,87,42 target4,22,3,7,,}], ); use warnings q{qw}; my %merged; for my $file (@file_data) { for my $line (@$file) { my ($row_val, @values) = split /,/ => $line; for (0 .. $#values) { if (! defined $merged{$row_val}[$_] or ( ! length $merged{$row_val}[$_] and length $values[$_] ) ) { $merged{$row_val}[$_] = $values[$_]; } } } } say join q{,} => $_, @{$merged{$_}} for sort keys %merged; ' target1,48,12,7,51,8,13 target2,17,16,2,87,42,8 target3,22,6,1 target4,22,3,7,11,5,6 target5,14,12,8,,3 target6,5,7,9,,,15