Beefy Boxes and Bandwidth Generously Provided by pair Networks
Perl Monk, Perl Meditation

Re: Hash Manipulation

by haukex (Bishop)
on Jun 08, 2021 at 07:20 UTC ( #11133647=note: print w/replies, xml ) Need Help??

in reply to Hash Manipulation

The main issue with the code you've shown is that in the three places you're doing something like $HashCount{$Screenkey} = {$i => "..."}, you're replacing what's stored in $HashCount{$Screenkey} with a new reference to a new anonymous hash, instead of adding something to the existing hash. You can delete the line $HashCount{$Screenkey} = $Screenkey; since that value is going to get replaced anyway. Then, you can replace the three aforementioned hash accesses with $HashCount{$Screenkey}{0} and $HashCount{$Screenkey}{$i} respectively - what this does is take advantage of a Perl feature called autovivification, which means that simply accessing $HashCount{$Screenkey} as if it were a reference to a hash causes a new anonymous hash to be created for you.

I think you've also got a logic issue with $i - in the case that $Screenkey ne $ScreenkeyOld, I am guessing that you probably want to start the numbering over - but you're only resetting $i=1 after already having used its previous value. The same goes for $i++. If I fix this, the next issue is that I think you've got a mistake in your sample data: since you're iterating over the sorted keys of %hash, Alarms will come first, but in your sample data you seem to expect the order to be Trend to USB, Alarms, and Flow Diagram. I haven't fixed this issue in the code below.

In general, note that you have two unused variables, @List and the outer $Screenkey, since you're only using the second $Screenkey defined inside the loop. Also, your code would benefit from better indentation - perltidy can help with that. And you can do away with %ScreenNameCount, since you can do that operation directly in %HashCount.

Putting all of that together (as mentioned above the test will fail since I haven't changed the order of the expected output you showed in your question):

use warnings; use strict; my %hash = ( 'Alarms.Alarm Acknowledge' => { 'ScreenName' => 'Alarms', 'Description' => 'Alarm Acknowledge', 'Type' => 'On/Off', }, 'Flow Diagram.Sequence Hold' => { 'ScreenName' => 'Flow Diagram', 'Description' => 'Sequence Hold', 'Type' => 'Momentary', }, 'Flow Diagram.Sequence Advance' => { 'ScreenName' => 'Flow Diagram', 'Description' => 'Sequence Advance', 'Type' => 'Momentary', }, 'Flow Diagram.Sanitize Enable/Disable' => { 'ScreenName' => 'Flow Diagram', 'Description' => 'Sanitize Enable/Disable', 'Type' => 'On/Off', }, 'Trend to USB.Start/Stop Trend Toggle' => { 'ScreenName' => 'Trend to USB', 'Description' => 'Start/Stop Trend Toggle', 'Type' => 'On/Off', }, 'Alarms.Alarm Reset' => { 'ScreenName' => 'Alarms', 'Description' => 'Alarm Reset', 'Type' => 'On/Off', }, 'Alarms.Alarm Trigger' => { 'ScreenName' => 'Alarms', 'Description' => 'Alarm Trigger', 'Type' => 'Momentary', }, ); my %HashCount; $HashCount{ $hash{$_}{ScreenName} }{0}++ foreach keys %hash; my $ScreenkeyOld = 'Old'; my $i = 1; foreach my $key ( sort keys %hash ) { my $Screenkey = $hash{$key}{ScreenName}; my $Description = $hash{$key}{Description}; my $Type = $hash{$key}{Type}; if ( $Screenkey eq $ScreenkeyOld ) { $i++; #print "$Screenkey <$i>\n"; #Debug $HashCount{$Screenkey}{$i} = "\\t \\t \\t \\t\& \\mytabhead{$D +escription} \\t\& $Type \\t\\\\ \\hline \\n $i - $Screenkey - $Screen +keyOld"; } else { $i = 1; #print "$ScreenkeyOld -> $Screenkey <$i>\n"; #Debug $HashCount{$Screenkey}{$i} = "\\mytabhead{$Screenkey} \\t\& \\ +mytabhead{$Description} \\t\& $Type \\t\\\\ \\hline \\n $i - $Screenk +ey - $ScreenkeyOld"; } $ScreenkeyOld = $Screenkey; } use Test::More tests=>1; is_deeply \%HashCount, { 'Alarms' => { '0' => 3, '1' => '\\mytabhead{Alarms} \\t& \\mytabhead{Alarm Trigger} \ +\t& Momentary \\t\\\\ \\hline \\n 1 - Alarms - Trend to USB', '2' => '\\t \\t \\t \\t& \\mytabhead{Alarm Acknowledge} \\t& O +n/Off \\t\\\\ \\hline \\n 2 - Alarms - Alarms', '3' => '\\t \\t \\t \\t& \\mytabhead{Alarm Reset} \\t& On/Off +\\t\\\\ \\hline \\n 3 - Alarms - Alarms', }, 'Flow Diagram' => { '0' => 3, '1' => '\\mytabhead{Flow Diagram} \\t& \\mytabhead{Sequence A +dvance} \\t& Momentary \\t\\\\ \\hline \\n 1 - Flow Diagram - Alarms' +, '2' => '\\t \\t \\t \\t& \\mytabhead{Sequence Hold} \\t& Momen +tary \\t\\\\ \\hline \\n 2 - Flow Diagram - Flow Diagram', '3' => '\\t \\t \\t \\t& \\mytabhead{Sanitize Enable/Disable} +\\t& On/Off \\t\\\\ \\hline \\n 3 - Flow Diagram - Flow Diagram', }, 'Trend to USB' => { '0' => 1, '1' => '\\mytabhead{Trend to USB} \\t& \\mytabhead{Start/Stop +Trend Toggle} \\t& On/Off \\t\\\\ \\hline \\n 1 - Trend to USB - Old' +, }, } or diag explain \%HashCount;

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^2: Hash Manipulation
by JusaEngineer (Novice) on Jun 08, 2021 at 13:53 UTC

    Thank you for your insight. You have solved some of my issues and moved me along. I'm getting the data in the format I would like it. I am able to print the screens with the correct number of buttons in the "\multirow{??}".
    The only issue I have now that is keeping me from completing this is, counting down buttons available per page and then formatting the changes to "\multirow{??}" as it is effected by being split between pages.
    Sorry about the order of the sorted elements, I wasn't thinking about it when I was typing up the sample result. I was trying to make sure that a $key was page broken.

    This is what I have now. I think that if I manipulate a few more if statements I can count down remaining buttons and check that each time that $ele = 0, to determine if I need to split it and update the "\multirow{??}". I may need to count down buttons per screen remaining also.

    my $MaxButtons = 5; my $RemainingButtons = $MaxButtons; my $ButtonsOnPage = 0; for $key (sort keys %HashCount) { for $ele (sort keys %{$HashCount{$key}}) { if ($ele eq 0){ } else { if ($ele eq 1){ print "\\multirow{$HashCount{$key}->{0}}{0.85in}{\\myt +abhead{$key}} \& " . $HashCount{$key}->{$ele} . "\n"; } else { print " \& " . $HashCount{$key}->{$ele} . "\n"; } } } }

      In your code you have this block (I've shortened the print statements for clarity):

      if ($ele eq 0){ } else { if ($ele eq 1){ print "Condition: ele is 1\n"; } else { print "Condition: ele is neither 1 nor 0\n"; } }

      This is confusing because of the empty block straddling the first 2 lines. There are a couple of ways to avoid it in general. One is to negate the condition:

      if ($ele ne 0){ if ($ele eq 1){ print "Condition: ele is 1\n"; } else { print "Condition: ele is neither 1 nor 0\n"; } }

      The other is to turn the if into an unless:

      unless ($ele eq 0){ if ($ele eq 1){ print "Condition: ele is 1\n"; } else { print "Condition: ele is neither 1 nor 0\n"; } }

      Either of these removes the empty block, so that's a plus. But we can go farther. The logic can be simplified because really you have only 2 conditions as indicated by my rewritten print statements. So we can remove the outer condition by folding it into the else like so:

      if ($ele eq 1){ print "Condition: ele is 1\n"; } elsif ($ele ne 0) { print "Condition: ele is neither 1 nor 0\n"; }

      Finally, deducing from your previous code that $ele is only ever a whole number you can switch to using numerical comparisons rather than string comparisons (== instead of eq, etc.). Perhaps this is the clearest:

      if ($ele == 1) { print "Condition: ele is 1\n"; } elsif ($ele > 1) { print "Condition: ele is neither 1 nor 0\n"; }

      I understand that you are just hacking about with this code but wanted to point out these alternative ways of going about the logical if-blocks. The simpler you can make it the fewer bugs can creep in and that has to be a good thing.


Log In?

What's my password?
Create A New User
Domain Nodelet?
Node Status?
node history
Node Type: note [id://11133647]
and the web crawler heard nothing...

How do I use this? | Other CB clients
Other Users?
Others examining the Monastery: (3)
As of 2021-07-31 22:19 GMT
Find Nodes?
    Voting Booth?

    No recent polls found