Serializing coderefs

[jmerelo]

Hi, I am trying to store code into XML, and I have bumped into CODEREFS. If I have a ref-to-subroutine, ¿how can I access the code? I know it invoves doing something with B::Generate, B, and possibly B::Utils, and this article seems to point the way. But I can't find a direct way of doing it. Looks like the latestest version of Data::Dumper does it also, but not the version of having it installed. Shouldn't coderefs be considered the same as array refs or hash refs?

[jmerelo]

I'm trying to do it using B::Utils. Looks like I'm wrong, since this code:

#!/usr/bin/perl
my $s = sub { my $k = shift; return $k;};
use B::Utils qw( walkoptree_simple );
print walkoptree_simple( $s, { print } );

issues an error: Can't call method "isa" on unblessed reference looks like B::Utils does not work with coderefs. Any hint?

[jmerelo]

Looks like this does the job:

my $s = sub { my $k = shift; return $k;};
use B::Deparse;
my $deparse = B::Deparse->new("-p", "-sC");
print  $deparse->coderef2text($s);

The morale here: when in doubt, ask, but don't wait for the answer, work on it...

[Aristotle]

I don't want to be adverse, but between your last post and the first one lie barely 30 minutes. The intermediate post makes it seem even more fidgety. I hope it's not the norm for you to ask questions you can answer for yourself within half an hour - an occasional occurence is very forgivable as even the best of us get stuck in boneheaded mode sometimes, but we are all expected to try and avoid false impatience.

Makeshifts last the longest.

[merlyn]

That of course "does the job" for a limited subset of coderefs, since at the moment there's no way to know the closure bindings (or get at them for their current values), so it'll come back to life pointing at an entirely wrong set of closure-bound variables.

This is a known issue, and being considered during the development of the Perl6 runtime engine.

-- Randal L. Schwartz, Perl hacker