Re: Re: Re^2: There's a level in Hell reserved for ________

[jdporter]

the generally accepted style for Perl??? I think not! Sure, it's a meme that gets around. But it's sucky, and needs to be squashed by anyone and everyone who thinks about it consciously. Put simply, there is no reason to do it that way, and there are good reasons not to do it that way.

jdporter
The 6th Rule of Perl Club is -- There is no Rule #6.

[perrin]

I've always used this style for args:

my_function_call(
                 $arg1,
                 $arg2,
                 $arg3,
                );

And for really long ones that would wrap, I do something like this:

My::Module::With::Really::Long::Name::and_function_call(
    $arg1,
    $arg2,
    $arg3,
                                                       );

Keeping each arg on a separate line makes them easy to read and easy to change, in my opinion. It is the most common style I've seen in use by experienced Perl programmers.

[Aristotle]

I always write them like so:

my_function_call(
    $arg1,
    $arg2,
    $arg3,
);

I indent all blocks, whether they be code, anonymous array/hash constructors, parameter (or other) lists, or anything else in the same way. Makes a lot of sense, if you ask me, when you're nesting calls:

my_function_call(
    my_other_function_call(
        $arg1,
        $arg2,
        and_yet_one_more_function_call(
            $arg1,
            $arg2,
            $arg3,
        ),
    ),
    $arg2,
    $arg3,
);

Compare:

my_function_call(
                 my_other_function_call(
                                        $arg1,
                                        $arg2,
                                        and_yet_one_more_function_call
+(
                                                                      
+ $arg1,
                                                                      
+ $arg2,
                                                                      
+ $arg3,
                                                                      
+),
                                       ),
                 $arg2,
                 $arg3,
                );

Yuck, if I may say so.

Makeshifts last the longest.

[Anonymous Monk]

I do as Aristotle does. That way if I have to change the line on which the function call is made, I don't have to reindent the arguments.