Net::Ping troubles

[Ovid]

I can't seem to get the following to work on my machine:

use warnings;
use strict;
use Net::Ping;

my @hosts = qw( www.ovidinexile.com www.yahoo.com 127.0.0.1 www.perlmo
+nks.org );
my $p = Net::Ping->new();

foreach my $host ( @hosts ) {
    print "$host\t" . $p->ping( $host ) . "\n";
}

The output is as follows:

www.ovidinexile.com     0
www.yahoo.com   0
127.0.0.1       0
www.perlmonks.org       0

I can successfully ping all of those from the command line. My reading the POD, the holy Cookbook, and several PM posts has failed to enlighten me. Chatterbox commentary has been interesting, but also unenlighting (though I had to run to a meeting after a bit -- maybe I missed something).

Using the icmp ping gives me the following error message:

icmp socket error - Unknown error at C:\WINNT\profiles\cp\desktop\ping
+.pl line 6

The tcp ping is unavailable because alarm is not supported on Windows NT (naturally, it doesn't have a decent ping program, either).

About the only thing I can think of is to use the system command and parse the response. Yuck! Anyone know what's wrong with my code?

Using WinNT 4.0 with ActiveState Perl 5.6.0.

Cheers,
Ovid

Join the Perlmonks Setiathome Group or just click on the the link and check out our stats.

[jcwren]

The 3 possible values for the new() are 'udp', 'tcp', and 'icmp'. If I use 'icmp' or 'tcp', it works for me, although the pings are a little squirrley because of the firewall ('icmp' works, 'tcp' does not). However, using new() with no arguments defaults to 'udp'. When explicity specifying 'udp', I get the following errors:

Use of uninitialized value at /usr/lib/perl5/5.00503/i386-linux/Socket
+.pm line 295.
Bad arg length for Socket::unpack_sockaddr_in, length is 0, should be 
+16 at /usr/lib/perl5/5.00503/i386-linux/Socket.pm line 295.

--Chris

e-mail jcwren

[tye]

Doing TCP or UDP pings is often useless since most machines (at least these days) don't service the TCP/UDP echo services. This type of "ping" is like trying to telnet to port 7 of a machine. Most of the time this will just get you "connection refused" because nothing listens to that port on so many machines. But since UDP is not connection oriented, you can't get "connection refused" so the ping just fails.

So you want to do Net::Ping->new("icmp"), which works for me. You need to get at 0+$! in order to understand what "unknown error" really is so we can figure out what is going wrong. Either modify Ping.pm so that it reports this or use the Perl debugger to step into Ping.pm and query what that value is. Perhaps you have to be "administrator" in order to use ICMP under WinNT?

        - tye (but my friends call me "Tye")

[Ovid]

Apparently, I do need to run this as administrator and do an icmp ping. Worked fine once I did that. I made the mistake of assuming that since I was told that UDP pings on our boxes were okay, that they were okay :(

Thanks for the help! I'll break out a can of ++ when my new shipment comes in tomorrow.

Ovid makes a note to always test assumptions.

Cheers,
Ovid

Update: Anyone know why the ping request works from a command line on NT and not from a Perl script? The NT documentation states that NT's ping uses icmp.

Join the Perlmonks Setiathome Group or just click on the the link and check out our stats.

[little]

out of the docs:


Net::Ping->new([$proto [, $def_timeout [, $bytes]]]);

Create a new ping object. All of the parameters are optional.
$proto specifies the protocol to use when doing a ping.
The current choices are ``tcp'', ``udp'' or ``icmp''.
The default is ``udp''.

Do u use the right proto ?

Have a nice day
All decision is left to your taste
Update
ack, I get old and slower

[Fastolfe]

He says he's tried them all.. With UDP he gets zeros, with ICMP he gets an error message, and with TCP he gets an error about alarm not being supported on NT.

[little]

For me it worked fine under so are all the services available? TCP didn't want to work on Win98, so I've chosen icmp, which succeeded. ??

Have a nice day
All decision is left to your taste

[Fastolfe]

Do you need to be running as an administrator to utilize ICMP in this fashion under NT?