Perl Win32 Apache & mod_fcgid not working

[roey]

I have installed apache 2.2.15 with mod_fcgid on Windows XP SP3 and Activestate Perl (tried both 5.12 & 5.8.9) tried the perl example script in the mod_fcgid reference page but it is not working, however it does run as simple cgi I get this in error log

[Tue Dec 07 23:10:35 2010] [info] mod_fcgid: server 127.0.0.1:/usr/bin
+/perl.exe(5476) started 
[Tue Dec 07 23:10:35 2010] [warn] [client 127.0.0.1] (OS 109)The pipe 
+has been ended. : mod_fcgid : get overlap result error 
[Tue Dec 07 23:10:35 2010] [error] [client 127.0.0.1] Premature end of
+ script headers: f.pl 
[Tue Dec 07 23:10:35 2010] [error] [client 127.0.0.1] File does not ex
+ist: C:/Apache2/htdocs/favicon.ico 
[Tue Dec 07 23:10:39 2010] [info] mod_fcgid - infoneto: process /usr/b
+in/perl.exe(5476) exit(communication error), return code 9

I double check everything including: The #!/usr/bin/perl.exe line The mod_fcgid is loaded (Yes it is on c:\usr\bin\perl.exe in may case...) When running the script as plain cgi it works When I turned to the older mod_fastcgi it works just fine as a fastcgi (i.e. loads once runs many times). Using process monitor I can see that apache starts Perl but it Perl exits almost instantly without even loading the Perl script I tried it also on Apache 2.0.52 & 2.0.63 with older mod_fcgid and with Apache 2.2.15 with the newest mod_fcgid (2.3.6) but no luck What can be done ? I googled around but no one seems to have solution or managed using mod_fcgid with perl on Win32 I opened a bug on both FCGI at cpan and on apache tracker but no one seems to care... Is there a solution for this ? Does someone else need this ? (mod_fcgid with Perl on Apache/Win32) This is the code I am trying:

#!/usr/bin/perl.exe
use FCGI;

my $count = 0;
my $request = FCGI::Request();

while($request->Accept() >= 0) {
   print("Content-type: text/html\r\n\r\n", ++$count);
}

[Corion]

It seems you reported that bug half a year ago via RT. I would guess that there is some kind of bug you encounter. Have you tried launching your (FCGI) script stand-alone from the console and seeing whether that produces an error? Also try redirecting STDERR to a file to see whether Perl creates an error. Maybe add sleep calls to delay the premature exit, just to convince yourself that Apache launches Perl and that Perl enters the ->Accept loop.

[roey]

* Have you tried launching your (FCGI) script stand-alone from the console and seeing whether that produces an error?
--- Yes - it works and it works a regular cgi as well

* try redirecting STDERR to a file to see whether Perl creates an error
--- Tried it - the script is not even started to run

* Maybe add sleep calls to delay the premature exit, just to convince yourself that Apache launches Perl and that Perl enters the ->Accept loop.
--- Well apache launches perl - but perl just closes and it is not loading the script

The main point Perl stats and exits due to some communication error with mod_fcgid.

[Anonymous Monk]

Do not use mod_fcgid with perl on MS Windows as it simply does not work.

I recommend using mod_fastcgi instead - you can get binaries (built for Apache 2.2.x by me) from http://strawberryperl.com/package/kmx/mod_fastcgi/

As for the shebang line you'd better use the full path to your perl.exe, just replace backslashes for slashes e.g.

#!c:/usr/bin/perl.exe

Another useful URL might be Catalyst+Apache+FastCGI on MS Windows

--
kmx

[Anonymous Monk]

Do not use mod_fcgid with perl on MS Windows as it simply does not work.

OK - why odes it not work ? what is broken ? currently mod_fcgid is the official way to use fastcgi on apache and mod_fastcgi is old ...

anyway thanks for the link, I will check it - I had many problems with mod_fastcgi

[Anonymous Monk]

The article linked doesn't explain why

For running Catalyst application as FastCGI on Apache/Win32 you have to choose mod_fastcgi (the author of this article did not manage after many tries to run catalyst app via mod_fcgid).

 

If you're quoting someone, use

<blockquote> the quote </blockquote>
your response

or

<i> the quote </i>
<p>your response

<dl<dt> the quote </dt>
<dd> your response
</dd></dl>