This is a hash of hash references that contain array references. (I think ;)
To print them out, you have to dereference the entire structure as an array. See the full sample program below for further details on this dereferencing and accessing individual elements.
say @{ $An{$id}->{b} };
I couldn't find the original thread, so I have no idea what is in the lettered arrays, so I just threw something together as an example:
#!/usr/bin/perl
use warnings;
use strict;
use 5.10.0;
my @bb = ( 41..60 );
my @cc = ( 21..40 );
my @IDs = ( 1..20 );
my %An;
my $idx = 0;
foreach my $n (@IDs) {
push @{$An{$n}->{b}} , $bb[$idx];
push @{$An{$n}->{c}} , $cc[$idx];
$idx++;
}
# $An{$id}->{b} is an array reference.
# To access its elements, we must dereference it
# by encompassing the data structure within the
# array dereferencing operator: @{}
# to iterate over the entire array reference
# note the @{} block surrounding the data structure
say map { $_, ' ' } @{ $An{1}->{b} };
# to print out a single element of the aref
say @{ $An{1}->{b} }[0];
# to print out the zeroeth element contained
# in the 'b' value of each %An ID key:
for my $id ( @IDs ){
say @{ $An{ $id }->{ b } }[0];
}
As for your other question, you should always declare your variables in the smallest scope possible... ie. as close to the block you are going to use them in, and where possible, within the block you'll use them in. Having a whole boatload of variables declared needlessly at the top of the program is both unsightly and makes for hard to follow code.