Re^2: On goto

[Aristotle]

{
    ask('databasetype','Database type?','mysql');
    output("Sorry, invalid option\n\n"), redo
        if not grep getConf('databasetype') eq $_, @databases;
}

Unless @databases is so large that you need the short-circuiting behaviour of the foreach version.

Makeshifts last the longest.

[merlyn]

That's fine if you're golfing.

I tend to be a bit more explicit in code that I'm leaving around for someone else to read. That last statement has about six semantic steps that partially nest, partially flow right to left, and partially flow left to right, without the help of denotational punctuation to help me "change gears".

It's also riddled with booby traps for the maintainer. The parens on output are mandatory, or else the redo would trigger before the function is called. If the expression for the test gets more complicated, or wants to be called only once, there's a bit of gyrating to do.

I figure anything that takes me more than a dozen seconds to parse needs to be broken up for production code. My personal rule.

See, if you were just going for compact, I'd slide that even further to:

output("Sorry, invalid option\n\n")
  until
    ask('database','Database type?', 'mysql'),
    grep getConf('databasetype') eq $_, @databases;

This gets rid of the naked block entirely.

But again, I would not use this in production code. This is cute to impress your friends, especially your Lisp-hacking friends. But it really aggravates the maintainer who has to try to grok that at 3am when the production web site crashes.

-- Randal L. Schwartz, Perl hacker
Be sure to read my standard disclaimer if this is a reply.

[Aristotle]

No, I was not golfing. You're right that it could do with just a hint more punctuation - grep BLOCK would be better than grep EXPR here.

I disagree that it's hard to understand - only if you've never seen that grep idiom before. Personally I use it all the time, so I don't even have to think about it when I read one anymore.

I do think it reads naturally:

Ask   for   a database type   (default is mysql).
Say "Sorry",   then try again
      if you can't   find   an entry   like   the requested database   in the list of databases.

I like to choose my code structure so that it maps as closely to a natural language description of what it's trying to do as possible.

In contrast, I'd never use your no-block example because it violates that principle.

Makeshifts last the longest.