I was a little surprised it could be used in a one-off script like this, myself. (That said, it's a great simple example!) SPOPS wasn't really designed for this sort of thing -- it was originally designed for server applications using lots of objects related to one another. That's why I assumed creating a subroutine to fetch the database handle wouldn't be a big deal. (As jeffa mentioned, I've since added a helper class to the SPOPS distribution so you can specify the DBI or LDAP connection info in the object configuration. Feedback is good!)

So if you could do this more tersely (even one-line) in other tools, great! However, there are many features that SPOPS has that makes it more than just an object-relational (or DBI-wrapper) tool.

- It supports other datasources than DBI. You can have pretty much all the same functionality with objects in LDAP directories, including manipulating them across different directories. You can also create relationships between objects on different databases.

- You can add transparent behaviors to the persistence functionality. For instance, if we were going to create an application using jeffa's core idea, we might want to fill in holes in the ID info from the MP3 -- maybe the genre is left out or something else. It's very simple to create a 'rule' that gets triggered before the object is saved to check a CDDB source and find our missing information. Then in our application we never have to worry about having all the correct information -- the object will do it for us. (You can use these rules to do just about anything :-)

In any case, as always: use the tool most appropriate for the job. IMO, there's no competition here with any of the POOP stuff. I know I'm not bashful about swiping features from other modules :-) And what will be superfly is if the P5EE effort is able to create an API for object persistence. Then no matter what implementing module you used, your code would look the same.

Chris
M-x auto-bs-mode


In reply to Re: SPOPS compared with SQL::Catalog + DBIx by lachoy
in thread Save MP3 Tag's to Database with SPOPS by jeffa

Title:
Use:  <p> text here (a paragraph) </p>
and:  <code> code here </code>
to format your post; it's "PerlMonks-approved HTML":