RE (tilly) 1: Eulogy for the chatterbox

[tilly]

I would sum it up differently. I would quote from perlipc and say:

...be strict in what you provide...but be lenient in what you require...

(OK, they were talking about line terminators. But...)

I also firmly believe that the sooner people can put things behind them, the better.

(BTW I know the charm of allowing /msh to live, but the occasional disaster also happens. Can we kill it again?)

[Ozymandias]

Better to be lenient in what you provide, and strict in what you permit.

Or, another way, don't let a few bad apples spoil the harvest.

As for letting /msh continue; if it's that important, where you just couldn't bear to see it public, then use email. Or IRC. Or the telephone. Or write a (gasp) hard-copy letter and mail it. Why kill the fun of the occaisional amusing accident (and I've had my share) to save you the convenience of hitting the HOME key and looking before you hit "Talk"?

- email Ozymandias

[tilly]

You miss the point.

The point is not to spew random garbage out, but not to take every piece of junk and escalate it into a flame-war. (OTOH do give feedback. In private.)

As for /msh, well I do provide an email address when I think it is appropriate. Unfortunately should the other person be unwilling to take me up on that, and wants to continue in /tell - well that happened today.