The other reason is that I think the strict MVC model is not consistent with a good object oriented design . Not my own idea, there was a nice article that convinced me (it may have been the paper talked about here UPDATE: No, it was a different one, but making a similar point).

Now I have not much practice in OO programming and none in web programming, so don't listen to me. But the paper makes some very good points.

Also the data of my web project is very "departmentalized" (i.e. one web page would usually access two and write to one small part of the whole information), this makes files instead of a database possible and quite frankly I loathe databases when it comes to maintenance and debugging

Catalyst seems to adhere more strictly to the MVC design, with separation strictness and its reliance on a database, so that CGI::Application may be a better fit for me even though I also spotted some things I don't like there too.

I really haven't decided yet. For example catalyst seems to depend on database use, only the older of two books about Catalyst mentions how to avoid a database, but it still seems possible to do. Same with object handling. Maybe I have to do a prototype first to help me decide